So it’s mid-December, Hanukkah has been and gone, and the radio is playing a lot of Christmas music. It gets tiresome. To explain why, let me try an analogy, which is not meant to be offensive to anyone of any Christian confession, but to illustrate how someone who is decidedly not Christian can feel at this time of year.
Christmas music is a deep catalog of advertising jingles for hair spray.
Music has been associated with religion, pretty much all religion, since the get-go, and for good reason. If nothing else, it helps you remember words; if well done, music makes the words more appealing; better, words and music can act synergetically to poke at the parts of your brain that generate strong emotional responses. There’s large chunks of the Jewish liturgy that I remember only with music, and that the music and words together can make me feel the presence of the ineffable. Music sells religion like nothing else.
If you want to sell anything, whether Jesus or Jeeps, you’re going to want to hire the best tunesmiths, and you are going to want to really make a strong association between your product and the jingle. And really, in the case of religion, that’s been done. I can’t think of the words of the Kyrie without thinking of Bach, the Dies Irae without Verdi, and so on. Similarly, I can’t think of the music of Mozart’s Requiem without thinking of the words, and then thinking, at least on some level, of confutatis maledictis and other bits of Catholic dogma. Mostly, though, the music is good enough that I can tune out the dogma and focus on the music—it’s good enough to cast shade on the dogma.
Christmas music, though, is more like pop—catchy, sometimes very good, but by no means great or profound. Which means that it’s harder to ignore the words, and thus harder to ignore the message. Go ahead, try to think about “I’d like to teach the world to sing...” without having Coke come fizzing up in your head. I’m not a big fan of Coke, but it’s not irrelevant to me. I drink it, rarely, and in small amounts, and actually derive some pleasure from it. And that jingle is a perfect catchy pop song.
What drives me batty about Christmas music is that there are scores and scores of nearly perfect pop song-jingles; they have been played more relentlessly than any advertising jingle ever; and, they are all selling a product that is irrelevant to me and that I kind of don’t even like and think may be doing some harm in how it is used—let’s say, hairspray.
Both for philosophical and historical reasons, I have problems with Christianity (and I really don’t care for the artifice of beehive hairdos, and how historically half of humanity has been taught that it needs to value itself for its appearance). I find the concept of the Trinity kind of absurd (not to mention the idea of hair glued into weird shapes). True, it may work and provide meaning for some people (and the right hairdo may be instrumental in finding Mr. Right), not me. I can’t damn all of Christianity, but in the present the rise of fundamentalism is doing serious social and environmental harm (And aerosols contributed to the hole in the ozone layer, not to mention how spray cans contribute to pollution).
So this is why I am frustrated by the flood of Christmas carols. By living in this society, these incredibly catchy songs are burned into my brain. I don’t like their message, but I can’t help but have it playing in my head when I hear them. They are perfect jingles. I would really be OK never hearing them ever again.
Showing posts with label vexations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label vexations. Show all posts
Monday, December 17, 2018
Tuesday, June 26, 2018
Seriously, SCOTUS?
I am upset, but not entirely surprised, by the decisions that came out of the Supreme Court today. To paraphrase a saying about Jewish law, where there is a judicial will, there is a legal way. A majority of the Supreme Court is A-OK with the Republican slide towards fascism, so they will find a legal way, however crudely and illogically and inconsistently argued, to make it happen. And so we have an executive order that is completely inspired by religious bigotry being declared constitutionally acceptable—because the third revision had scrupulously neutral language—and using the overruling of Korematsu as justification!
When this presidency started, I was alarmed at the regulatory/executive and judicial mischief that it promised. What I was not prepared for, and what gives me increasing agony, is the deep and blatant racism and bigotry that it has made publicly acceptable.
When this presidency started, I was alarmed at the regulatory/executive and judicial mischief that it promised. What I was not prepared for, and what gives me increasing agony, is the deep and blatant racism and bigotry that it has made publicly acceptable.
Sunday, June 24, 2018
What’s my pre-Cambrian rabbit? What’s YOUR pre-Cambrian rabbit?
I try to be honest with myself in how I think about things. It is hard to be aware of one’s blind spots, and it is tiring to be suspicious of ideas that make one feel better. I may have picked up the habit of self-skepticism from an early exposure to Karl Popper, or a lot of training by curmudgeonly old-school molecular geneticists, but however I got it, I’m stuck with it. Popper taught us all about falsifiability, and my post-doc advisor taught me to have an adversarial relationship with my own ideas, but my favorite formulation is from the evolutionary biologist J.B.S. Haldane.
Evolution is a big, big concept, with ramifications that permeate the entire world of biology, geology, and astronomy, and more. But, to be honest about how one thinks, one must be aware that it’s still only an idea, a view of the world that may be wrong. Haldane was (according to the story) asked what would cause him to change his mind about evolution as an explanation for life on earth. “A fossil rabbit in the pre-Cambrian” was his reply. Pre-Cambrian rocks are over 500 million years old. There are pre-Cambrian fossils, but only of simple invertebrates and mysterious life forms long extinct. But, significantly, there are fossils; if there were rabbits 500 million years ago, they could have been fossilized, so it is in principle possible that Haldane’s reliance upon evolution could have been shaken.
Any responsible thinker should have a pre-Cambrian rabbit for their beliefs. The people who study climate change, if they were honest, would reconsider everything if it were found that carbon dioxide did not in fact help to trap heat, and that hundreds of years of data were in fact due to an easily overlooked artifact. Cancer researchers, if they were honest, would re-evaluate a lot of their beliefs if the apparent connection between smoking and lung cancer were shown to be the result of some chemical in the packaging of cigarette boxes. Furthermore, for an honest thinker, it’s not a matter of simply recognizing falsifying evidence when it appears. Rather, like Haldane, the honest thinker must be aware enough of their thinking that they can imagine and define things that would falsify their beliefs before encountering them.
The news recently has really been getting me down. I have become convinced of a theory that our president is a racist, and that his presidency will be severely detrimental to this country. This theory is based on observation of facts and informed by historical parallels. But, while it is consistent with all facts, it is a theory. It is, and must be, falsifiable. The president could decide to fire his Jeff Sessions and Stephen Miller and General Kelly and all the other people who have pushed him in the direction of racism, and renounce many of the claims he’s made; despite rigorous fact-checking, many of the claims he’s made about immigrants could be shown to be true (somehow); he could actually do things to promote racial harmony—these would all be possible but unlikely. They would falsify my theory, and elevate my mood.
But, I have noticed something more disturbing in the mirror world inhabited by those whose sympathies lie with the president. For them (and those who insist that anthropogenic climate change, vaccines, and evolution are bunk), there simply is no pre-Cambrian rabbit. There is no possible fact or observation that will change their position, and whether this is bad faith or just simple-mindedness, it makes rational argument impossible. When a Trump supporter at one of his tinpot “Triumph of the Will” rallies was asked about some of the images and recordings of children torn from their parents, they admitted that they were disturbing, but ultimately opined that they were probably faked. I’ve also heard dodges about how Trump is accomplishing great (but unspecified) things and how everybody is out to get him; and, finally, fake news, fake news, fake news. Even the most reliable, scrupulously reported pre-Cambrian rabbit is fake.
I don’t know a way beyond this impasse to civil discourse, although I’m pretty sure it doesn’t involve Facebook memes or using InfoWars as a reliable source. Perhaps any real attempt at discussion must be made one-on-one. Before attempting conversation, we have to tell each other about our pre-Cambrian rabbits. Acknowledging that our beliefs are falsifiable is the opposite of a sign of weakness; rather, it is a sign of honesty, like duelists of old showing each other that they are only using the prescribed weapons. Also, if you showed me a rabbit skull and told me it came from, say, the Laurentian Shield, I’d want to see some acceptable proof—and, like the rabbit itself, proof that I would be willing name as acceptable before it is produced.
I really doubt that a fossilized rabbit will ever be discovered in pre-Cambrian rocks. But, to be absolutely sure, I would be thrilled and excited to hear that a truly, completely verified rabbit fossil had been found in the basement sediments of the Grand Canyon. It would show me that I was working under an erroneous view of the world, and it would be fascinating to try to understand this newly illuminated world. And, while I would love to be wrong, I think that rabbit is more likely than finding that our president is not a racist.
Saturday, February 17, 2018
A modest proposal on gun control
A modest proposal for gun control.
There are very few consumer products that, when used as designed and intended, shorten or terminate human life. Cigarettes are one. There is a societal cost to cigarettes; every time a person inhales from one, society pays a price—the price is very diffuse, in minute fractions of years lived by inhalers of secondhand smoke. This cost is very hard to measure, but real. Society also pays by dealing with the expenses incurred by the diseases associated with long-term cigarette use. Society gets some compensation for these costs from cigarette users, in the form of heavy taxes imposed on the sale of cigarettes. Society also discourages further cigarette use with various advertising campaigns, and more recently, unofficial forces such as scorn and inconvenience.
Two more products that, when used as designed and intended, shorten or terminate human life are handguns and semiautomatic rifles (“assault rifles”). The societal cost of these consumer products is far more obvious than the cost of cigarettes, and per unit sold, these products do far more damage. Despite what the gun-makers’ lobby says about good guys with guns, there are numerous studies that indicate that more guns has the societal effect of more deaths and injuries from guns. The coefficient of the relationship has not been exactly defined, and varies regionally, but the relationship can’t really be honestly challenged. And, while cigarettes harm society at large but most severely harm their users, guns—especially assault rifles—cause far more harm to society at large (though the numbers are inexact, gun suicides account for something like half of gun fatalities).
The use of cigarettes harms society; society exacts some compensation from cigarette users. The use of handguns and assault rifles harms society; yet there is no equivalent penalty on the purchase of these guns. The price, as noted is gory, agonizing, traumatizing, and can upend lives in a way that cigarettes cannot.
There are various estimates for the number of excess deaths caused each year by handguns and assault rifles. Let us take the lowest of these estimates. There are a certain number of handguns and assault rifles purchased each year. Let us divide one by the other, to figure out the fractional number of deaths caused per year, on average, by such a weapon. Let us convert that into a probability—a probability of drawing a ticket in a lottery by which society claws something back. On purchasing such a weapon, the buyer is automatically entered into this lottery. If the buyer’s number comes up—such an unlikely thing!, the gun advocate says—but inevitable, the gun control advocate says—then, at some time that year, seemingly at random, someone near and dear to the gun purchaser, a child, a spouse, a favorite uncle, will be shot and maimed or killed.
“This is so unfair! The dear person did nothing wrong! You are a monster for suggesting such a thing!” I hear you say. Granted, it imposes some punishment on an innocent, but so does the gun purchaser anyway; the 17 who died this week in Florida, the concert goers in Vegas, the students just over the hill from me at Umpqua Community College, were equally innocent and undeserving. But, I didn’t mention the other price that the handguns and assault rifles impose on society—the tearing of societal fabric, the lasting trauma, the anger and hurt and pain that reverberates through a community for years afterwards. It’s hard to put a dollar valuation on that cost to society, and hard to extract that from the person buying the weapon. So, payment in kind. It may, have some deterrent effect on such purchases as well.
We are in a state where it is increasingly difficult to deny that the violent, terrorized deaths of children are the price that society pays for the freedom to have guns. I have even seen words to that effect from those that advocate for unrestricted access to guns. So, fine; they can maintain that right. All I ask is that those who want to exercise that right pay their fair share of the price.
There are very few consumer products that, when used as designed and intended, shorten or terminate human life. Cigarettes are one. There is a societal cost to cigarettes; every time a person inhales from one, society pays a price—the price is very diffuse, in minute fractions of years lived by inhalers of secondhand smoke. This cost is very hard to measure, but real. Society also pays by dealing with the expenses incurred by the diseases associated with long-term cigarette use. Society gets some compensation for these costs from cigarette users, in the form of heavy taxes imposed on the sale of cigarettes. Society also discourages further cigarette use with various advertising campaigns, and more recently, unofficial forces such as scorn and inconvenience.
Two more products that, when used as designed and intended, shorten or terminate human life are handguns and semiautomatic rifles (“assault rifles”). The societal cost of these consumer products is far more obvious than the cost of cigarettes, and per unit sold, these products do far more damage. Despite what the gun-makers’ lobby says about good guys with guns, there are numerous studies that indicate that more guns has the societal effect of more deaths and injuries from guns. The coefficient of the relationship has not been exactly defined, and varies regionally, but the relationship can’t really be honestly challenged. And, while cigarettes harm society at large but most severely harm their users, guns—especially assault rifles—cause far more harm to society at large (though the numbers are inexact, gun suicides account for something like half of gun fatalities).
The use of cigarettes harms society; society exacts some compensation from cigarette users. The use of handguns and assault rifles harms society; yet there is no equivalent penalty on the purchase of these guns. The price, as noted is gory, agonizing, traumatizing, and can upend lives in a way that cigarettes cannot.
There are various estimates for the number of excess deaths caused each year by handguns and assault rifles. Let us take the lowest of these estimates. There are a certain number of handguns and assault rifles purchased each year. Let us divide one by the other, to figure out the fractional number of deaths caused per year, on average, by such a weapon. Let us convert that into a probability—a probability of drawing a ticket in a lottery by which society claws something back. On purchasing such a weapon, the buyer is automatically entered into this lottery. If the buyer’s number comes up—such an unlikely thing!, the gun advocate says—but inevitable, the gun control advocate says—then, at some time that year, seemingly at random, someone near and dear to the gun purchaser, a child, a spouse, a favorite uncle, will be shot and maimed or killed.
“This is so unfair! The dear person did nothing wrong! You are a monster for suggesting such a thing!” I hear you say. Granted, it imposes some punishment on an innocent, but so does the gun purchaser anyway; the 17 who died this week in Florida, the concert goers in Vegas, the students just over the hill from me at Umpqua Community College, were equally innocent and undeserving. But, I didn’t mention the other price that the handguns and assault rifles impose on society—the tearing of societal fabric, the lasting trauma, the anger and hurt and pain that reverberates through a community for years afterwards. It’s hard to put a dollar valuation on that cost to society, and hard to extract that from the person buying the weapon. So, payment in kind. It may, have some deterrent effect on such purchases as well.
We are in a state where it is increasingly difficult to deny that the violent, terrorized deaths of children are the price that society pays for the freedom to have guns. I have even seen words to that effect from those that advocate for unrestricted access to guns. So, fine; they can maintain that right. All I ask is that those who want to exercise that right pay their fair share of the price.
Monday, October 2, 2017
Incoherent rant
Last week's news should have been all about Puerto Rico dealing with the destruction of a hurricane. Instead, too much of it was focused on the rantings of a bigot who has spent his life wiping his ass with the American flag, complaining about people who have a legitimate problem respectfully exercising their right to protest. The bigot confused respectful protest with disrespect for the flag and the soldiers who fought under it. The bigot also thought that the soldiers fought for the flag and not for the values it represents.
The bigot, and the party of whom he is the leader, are dedicated to the primacy of the second amendment to the constitution, or specifically one phrase thereof. To the bigot and his party, this one isolated phrase, stripped of its modifying companion in its sentence, is sacred.
Last night, facilitated by the bigot's party, a guy armed with military weapons (and not acting as part of a well-regulated militia) opened fire on a crowd in Las Vegas, killing (as of this time) 59 people and wounding hundreds.
As I drove through town today, the flag at the National Cemetery was at half-mast, per the bigot's orders. As I listened to the radio recounting the night's events, I had to wonder if the people now interred under those ranks and ranks of tombstones were really serving, fighting, and dying so that a guy could legally arm himself with a platoon's weapons and kill and injure so many citizens. Would any of them be moved to rise from the earth and yell like banshees at the bigot and his party? Could they shamble out of their graves and trouble the dreams of the bigot and his party? Could one of them gesture at regiments of the risen dead, and point out the bit of the constitution that mentions a well-regulated militia?
I don't think that the dead at the National Cemetery can do this, and I don't think that the dead from Las Vegas this week can teach the bigot or his party either. Nor can the dead from Roseburg, two years ago, or Sandy Hook or Columbine or Aurora. I don't think anything can teach the bigot or his party. I don't think anything can teach half of our country, either. I am not feeling optimistic tonight.
The bigot, and the party of whom he is the leader, are dedicated to the primacy of the second amendment to the constitution, or specifically one phrase thereof. To the bigot and his party, this one isolated phrase, stripped of its modifying companion in its sentence, is sacred.
Last night, facilitated by the bigot's party, a guy armed with military weapons (and not acting as part of a well-regulated militia) opened fire on a crowd in Las Vegas, killing (as of this time) 59 people and wounding hundreds.
As I drove through town today, the flag at the National Cemetery was at half-mast, per the bigot's orders. As I listened to the radio recounting the night's events, I had to wonder if the people now interred under those ranks and ranks of tombstones were really serving, fighting, and dying so that a guy could legally arm himself with a platoon's weapons and kill and injure so many citizens. Would any of them be moved to rise from the earth and yell like banshees at the bigot and his party? Could they shamble out of their graves and trouble the dreams of the bigot and his party? Could one of them gesture at regiments of the risen dead, and point out the bit of the constitution that mentions a well-regulated militia?
I don't think that the dead at the National Cemetery can do this, and I don't think that the dead from Las Vegas this week can teach the bigot or his party either. Nor can the dead from Roseburg, two years ago, or Sandy Hook or Columbine or Aurora. I don't think anything can teach the bigot or his party. I don't think anything can teach half of our country, either. I am not feeling optimistic tonight.
Tuesday, April 18, 2017
Monday Musical Offering Running Flat Edition
I love me some Schubert. Pleasant, lyrical, often sight-readable...until you stumble onto a section in A-flat minor. I mean, come on! Seven flats!
Sunday, January 29, 2017
Frustrations
Scrambled all my plans and spent all morning dealing with a 3x1 dichtring and a 0.52 düsenscheibe.
(Partial explanation)
(Partial explanation)
Tuesday, November 1, 2016
Tuesday Tool Bioassay Edition
This Tuesday's tool is the voltage tester. It's a little doohickey with a probe that you stick in the ground, connected by a wire to a little box with a metal hook that you hang onto an electric fence. If the fence is "hot", then the box lights up. The stronger the voltage, the more lights. You use this to see if your electric fence is working like it's supposed to.
You can also use a ram for the same purpose. If he's scratching his head, flossing the gap between his horns with what is supposed to be the hot wire, then you can be pretty sure that your fence isn't working properly.
Wednesday, October 19, 2016
Wednesday Words Please Stop Edition
I like words, which is why there is a Wednesday Words theme here. I like them as things to play with, as objects that behave oddly, or that have curious histories. Language--what happens when words get strung together--is a bit different. I dislike the abuse of words, such as the use of "impact" as a verb or the myriad atrocities of businesspeak. But I have become horrified lately by the abuse of language, and I am going to ask you, who may read this, to help stamp it out.
The language in question conveys a meaning, one that is corrosive to society. We should, as individuals in society, recognize that we are all elements in a larger whole; that every other person in that larger whole is as much a person as we ourselves are. In short, we should have compassion. We may occasionally bump into each other the wrong way, we may intentionally or unintentionally slight one another, we may fail to live up to our ideals, miss the mark, or sin. If we do this, we should own up to the fact that we have wronged another person who is just as important as us, and as part of that, we should string together some words into language that expresses compassion and actually helps to make things better.
So, if you find yourself in this situation (and, being human, you will), do not use the following language:
"Mistakes were made." That's not in doubt. Who made them? As any editor will tell you, use the active voice.
"I regret if anybody took offense at my remarks." A dodge to throw things into the passive voice; it makes the action come from, and the blame fall upon, the person wronged.
"As the [relative] of a [female, minority, immigrant, person of minority faith, or other too-often-picked-on-group], I am appalled by so-and-so's statements." Compassion is recognizing the humanity of others. If you only recognize humanity when it's your own, you don't really have compassion.
Okay, I'm probably preaching to the choir here. But still, we are exposed to these dodges all too often, and those who commit violence to language go on their way freely. Do what you can to call them out. Heck, I'll even tolerate the use of "impact" as a verb if I could see these phrases disappear.
The language in question conveys a meaning, one that is corrosive to society. We should, as individuals in society, recognize that we are all elements in a larger whole; that every other person in that larger whole is as much a person as we ourselves are. In short, we should have compassion. We may occasionally bump into each other the wrong way, we may intentionally or unintentionally slight one another, we may fail to live up to our ideals, miss the mark, or sin. If we do this, we should own up to the fact that we have wronged another person who is just as important as us, and as part of that, we should string together some words into language that expresses compassion and actually helps to make things better.
So, if you find yourself in this situation (and, being human, you will), do not use the following language:
"Mistakes were made." That's not in doubt. Who made them? As any editor will tell you, use the active voice.
"I regret if anybody took offense at my remarks." A dodge to throw things into the passive voice; it makes the action come from, and the blame fall upon, the person wronged.
"As the [relative] of a [female, minority, immigrant, person of minority faith, or other too-often-picked-on-group], I am appalled by so-and-so's statements." Compassion is recognizing the humanity of others. If you only recognize humanity when it's your own, you don't really have compassion.
Okay, I'm probably preaching to the choir here. But still, we are exposed to these dodges all too often, and those who commit violence to language go on their way freely. Do what you can to call them out. Heck, I'll even tolerate the use of "impact" as a verb if I could see these phrases disappear.
Thursday, February 11, 2016
More late night thoughts after too much news and too much wine
I heard an interesting program on the radio (http://hereandnow.wbur.org/2016/02/10/prisons-around-the-world) about how prison is viewed in different countries. The U.S. was an early reformer of prisons, but (especially with the invention of privately-run prisons in the U.S.) we seem to have lost sight of what prison is about. Rehabilitation and reintegration into society have faded as goals, displaced by a stridently punitive attitude and an inhuman quest for profit. In some countries, however, there has been an increasing emphasis on making offenders, especially younger offenders, into useful members of society.
There's a lot going on there, and a lot of it has to do with wether or not we regard ourselves as a society. If you view society as a single entity, then healing society means healing the atoms that make it up. If you view the state as the representative of the will of society as a whole, then of course the state should use tax money to do this work.
If you follow the inspiration of Margaret Thatcher and the modern development of conservatism, then there is no such thing as society--we are all individuals, all for ourselves and against each other. A war on crime too easily becomes a war on "other"--other races, other classes. It becomes too easy to find support for locking people up and throwing away the key. It becomes too easy to yield to an animal demand for blood. Prisoners are not to be rehabilitated or given anything, only punished. The state is not us or our agent; it is also "other", so it has no more business looking after prisoners than, say, a private company. If state or company abuses prisoners on the way to making a profit, so what? It is always "other" getting hurt. And, as the researcher on the radio pointed out, as long as society doesn't exist and there is only "us" and "other," all "other"s are assumed to be bad. Indeed, that is precisely the dominant attitude in this well-armed neck of the woods.
I am too much of a collectivist to see the merit of this view, which has gained such traction in our country. I am too rooted in a tradition that encourages me to see all "others" as equally human. So I was pleased to hear about programs that could take people--mostly young adults--who had been failed by family or education, who had gone wrong and done wrong, being helped back onto a good path.
Then I heard other stories on the radio, about executives at a coal company deliberately endangering miners for profit, about executives of an energy company poisoning a river, about a leading presidential candidate enthusing about torture, about a government choosing to poison its constituents with lead, about a county sheriff who engaged in torture and abuse of prisoners, and so on. There are miscreants out there, and these folks have done a lot more to destroy the fabric of society than a punk with a revolver holding up a convenience store, or even a murderer or rapist. They have generally been doing what they do for twenty, thirty, fifty years. The longer they have done it, the more profit they've derived, the more firmly they believe in their actions' absolute righteousness. In most cases, they admit no wrongdoing, and such contrition as is seen is mouthed by their defense attorneys during their sentencing--and never again.
I don't know--can such people, who I must acknowledge as my fellow humans, be reformed? Can they be redeemed? Their energy and skills directed towards mending the society they've assaulted? Or is a punitive model appropriate for such people? How does society heal itself of such cancers? I do not know.
There's a lot going on there, and a lot of it has to do with wether or not we regard ourselves as a society. If you view society as a single entity, then healing society means healing the atoms that make it up. If you view the state as the representative of the will of society as a whole, then of course the state should use tax money to do this work.
If you follow the inspiration of Margaret Thatcher and the modern development of conservatism, then there is no such thing as society--we are all individuals, all for ourselves and against each other. A war on crime too easily becomes a war on "other"--other races, other classes. It becomes too easy to find support for locking people up and throwing away the key. It becomes too easy to yield to an animal demand for blood. Prisoners are not to be rehabilitated or given anything, only punished. The state is not us or our agent; it is also "other", so it has no more business looking after prisoners than, say, a private company. If state or company abuses prisoners on the way to making a profit, so what? It is always "other" getting hurt. And, as the researcher on the radio pointed out, as long as society doesn't exist and there is only "us" and "other," all "other"s are assumed to be bad. Indeed, that is precisely the dominant attitude in this well-armed neck of the woods.
I am too much of a collectivist to see the merit of this view, which has gained such traction in our country. I am too rooted in a tradition that encourages me to see all "others" as equally human. So I was pleased to hear about programs that could take people--mostly young adults--who had been failed by family or education, who had gone wrong and done wrong, being helped back onto a good path.
Then I heard other stories on the radio, about executives at a coal company deliberately endangering miners for profit, about executives of an energy company poisoning a river, about a leading presidential candidate enthusing about torture, about a government choosing to poison its constituents with lead, about a county sheriff who engaged in torture and abuse of prisoners, and so on. There are miscreants out there, and these folks have done a lot more to destroy the fabric of society than a punk with a revolver holding up a convenience store, or even a murderer or rapist. They have generally been doing what they do for twenty, thirty, fifty years. The longer they have done it, the more profit they've derived, the more firmly they believe in their actions' absolute righteousness. In most cases, they admit no wrongdoing, and such contrition as is seen is mouthed by their defense attorneys during their sentencing--and never again.
I don't know--can such people, who I must acknowledge as my fellow humans, be reformed? Can they be redeemed? Their energy and skills directed towards mending the society they've assaulted? Or is a punitive model appropriate for such people? How does society heal itself of such cancers? I do not know.
Wednesday, January 27, 2016
Wednesday Wordage...utterly lost in translation
I think there are two requirements for the written instruction sheets that come with new plumbing or HVAC bits or farm implements.
1. The instructions must be translated from another language. If the product was made in an Anglophone country, it must either use unfamiliar idioms or be translated into a non-Indo-European language and then translated back.
2. The instructions must specify at least one topological impossibility or make reference to a non-existent part that exists in a non-integral dimension.
3. There must be a part included in the bag of bits that is not mentioned anywhere in the instruction sheet. (An exception--you can see a reference to it in the Finnish instructions, but nowhere else.)
I seem to have run into all of these rules today.
1. The instructions must be translated from another language. If the product was made in an Anglophone country, it must either use unfamiliar idioms or be translated into a non-Indo-European language and then translated back.
2. The instructions must specify at least one topological impossibility or make reference to a non-existent part that exists in a non-integral dimension.
3. There must be a part included in the bag of bits that is not mentioned anywhere in the instruction sheet. (An exception--you can see a reference to it in the Finnish instructions, but nowhere else.)
I seem to have run into all of these rules today.
Sunday, January 17, 2016
I'll just leave this here...
A quote from the Ammon Bundy, leader of the brave patriots who have bravely taken over the Malheur Bird Sanctuary, on their role as the rightful caretakers of a large area with numerous Paiute artifacts and archaelogical sites:
"Before the white man came, so to speak, there was nothing to keep cattle from tromping on those things."
I will bet you a nickel that he believes that the earth is about 4000 years old.
"Before the white man came, so to speak, there was nothing to keep cattle from tromping on those things."
I will bet you a nickel that he believes that the earth is about 4000 years old.
Wednesday, August 26, 2015
Time and memory
I wrote that last post, and set it aside for a few days before I decided to publish it. I typically let what I write sit for a few days, so I can do a better job editing. At any rate, just before that post was scheduled to hit the web, the Real Doctor's sister, C., called to wish us a happy something-teenth anniversary of our wedding.
The coincident timing of a wedding anniversary and a post about time and love was a pure accident. Neither the Real Doctor nor I can remember the date of our wedding anniversary, nor have we ever. The date was set in part by the Hebrew calendar, a lunar calendar, so our anniversary changes relative to the common calendar every year. Also, by the time of our wedding, marriage was a foregone conclusion, so the date of its consecration wasn't critical. A more notable, memorable date for us is when McCoy Tyner played a gig in Madison, which was our first official date.
Besides, until recently, I haven't had to remember the date of our wedding anniversary. Every year, until two years ago, my mom would send us a nice, hand-made anniversary card; it would arrive about two days before our anniversary, and so we'd be reminded of the day with sufficient lead time to make sure that we had a decent bottle of wine or some cake on hand.
Alas, those days are in the past. My mom, who recently celebrated her 80th birthday, is fast disappearing into the fog of Alzheimer's Disease. It's a good day when she remembers which son I am (the one with the goats and sheep, up in Oregon). It's a very good day when she remembers that I'm married to the Real Doctor. Of course, the nature of things is that it will only get worse. She's still recognizably herself, but I don't know how long that will last. She is trailing my dad by about three years; however, Alzheimer's seems to progress more rapidly in women than men. So, alas, it goes.
My parents have been married for something like 55 years. My dad is beyond recognizing his wife, or anybody, or having any meaningful interaction with the world; his body persists in this world, but most of what was uniquely Michael Appleman left this world over a year ago. My mom, on the other hand, is still well aware of who my dad is--or rather, was. She knows her husband of decades past, and cannot remember that he is unable to walk, talk, recognize her, or in any way take care of himself. The fresh discovery of this, every day, is a cause of considerable sadness for her.
Which, I guess, is a reminder. While we're here, and alive, and aware--don't worry about anniversaries. Honor every day.
The coincident timing of a wedding anniversary and a post about time and love was a pure accident. Neither the Real Doctor nor I can remember the date of our wedding anniversary, nor have we ever. The date was set in part by the Hebrew calendar, a lunar calendar, so our anniversary changes relative to the common calendar every year. Also, by the time of our wedding, marriage was a foregone conclusion, so the date of its consecration wasn't critical. A more notable, memorable date for us is when McCoy Tyner played a gig in Madison, which was our first official date.
Besides, until recently, I haven't had to remember the date of our wedding anniversary. Every year, until two years ago, my mom would send us a nice, hand-made anniversary card; it would arrive about two days before our anniversary, and so we'd be reminded of the day with sufficient lead time to make sure that we had a decent bottle of wine or some cake on hand.
Alas, those days are in the past. My mom, who recently celebrated her 80th birthday, is fast disappearing into the fog of Alzheimer's Disease. It's a good day when she remembers which son I am (the one with the goats and sheep, up in Oregon). It's a very good day when she remembers that I'm married to the Real Doctor. Of course, the nature of things is that it will only get worse. She's still recognizably herself, but I don't know how long that will last. She is trailing my dad by about three years; however, Alzheimer's seems to progress more rapidly in women than men. So, alas, it goes.
My parents have been married for something like 55 years. My dad is beyond recognizing his wife, or anybody, or having any meaningful interaction with the world; his body persists in this world, but most of what was uniquely Michael Appleman left this world over a year ago. My mom, on the other hand, is still well aware of who my dad is--or rather, was. She knows her husband of decades past, and cannot remember that he is unable to walk, talk, recognize her, or in any way take care of himself. The fresh discovery of this, every day, is a cause of considerable sadness for her.
Which, I guess, is a reminder. While we're here, and alive, and aware--don't worry about anniversaries. Honor every day.
Labels:
%#$*ing Alzheimer's disease,
atmospherics,
vexations
Wednesday, November 19, 2014
Wednesday Wordage: Chiron, son of Chronos, god-like beast...
One of the many things that vexes me about the state of civil discourse these days has to do with qualifications, or more precisely, disqualifications. We have too many news and opinion shows on too many channels and blogs and twitters, all going 24/7. All of these outlets need people to voice opinions--otherwise, no show, and no ad revenue. But what does it take to be one of these opinion-spinners?
The qualifications are minimal. One can earn an advanced degree in seemingly any field, or you can be at a think-tank, or you can be an elected official, or you can have an obsessive blog about a particular subject, or be eloquent, or telegenic, or family of someone relevant, or any of a number of other things. All of these things, whatever their true worth at forming an educated opinion, apparently qualify you to share your opinion with lots of people, and try to sway their opinions.
What distresses me is not how easy it is to gain qualification as an opinion-maker. It is, rather, how it is nearly impossible to be disqualified as an opinioneer. There are too many people whose opinions are given far too much weight, based on how their previous opinions or policies have played out in the real world. They should, one thinks, be disqualified from having publicly broadcast opinions on these matters. We really should never have to listen to a news or opinion piece on human rights from Henry Kissinger, on middle-eastern policy from Dick Cheney, on defence policy from Don Rumsfeld, on presidential powers from John Yoo, on appropriate workplace behavior from Bill Clinton, and so on--except, perhaps to hear them say, "whatever you do, make it the opposite of what I did". But banning people is not the solution, or consistent with our constitution.
So, I argue for the return of the epithet. You may remember epithets from Homer and his ilk: swift-footed Achilles, Eos of the rosy fingers. In documented history, you have kings such as Ethelred the Unready or Ivan the Terrible. These adjectival phrases become part of the character's name. Epithets help us to grasp the essential nature of the person, and they're not always flattering.
There are certain positions or clearly stated opinions--not off-the-cuff remarks, but publicly declared views--that have been tested by time, and found stupid or odious. They become less like opinions and more like falsified hypotheses that are still, despite evidence, clung to. I propose that these should become epithets. However, it doesn't really advance public discourse when you reduce a talking head's world-view to a single adjective like "unready" or "terrible." A more useful and informative epithet, one that would help the audience to weigh an opinion, would be something such as "who thought Sarah Palin would be a good president" or "who reckons that bombing Iran would be constructive," to suggest a few that would apply to the Honorable Senator John McCain.
How does one deal with a bulky and cumbersome epithet such as this? A solution is provided by repurposing yet another scourge of public discourse, the Chyron. Chyrons (the name is apparently a trademark and has nothing to do with the centaur who taught Achilles; they are also called crawls or "the bottom third") are those lines of text that pollute the bottom of a TV screen whenever there is a talking head spouting opinions. They are generally full of garbage, or take the talking head's opinion an reduce it to one phrase of mush. Either way, they do nothing useful. I suggest taking the Chyron and using it to show the talking head's epithet.
Here's an example: nowadays, we see James Inhofe's head talking above lines of text saying "Sen (R) Okla / Jets 14 Ravens 3 (final) / Dow up 13 3/8 / Did Rhianna cheat on Ussher? / Volcanic eruption in Hawaii threatens golf course..." and so on. Instead, we should see James Inhofe talking above lines of text saying "despite a century of accumulated scientific evidence and the assurances of pretty much everybody who has studied them, he refuses to place any credence in biological evolution or anthropogenic climate change. Also gets lots of money from fossil fuel business." That way the viewer would know the talking head is venal and committed to ignorance on not just one, but two, and probably lots of issues.
It might be argued that this would stifle free discussion of important issues. But, if you consistently have opinions that the passage of time have shown to be clearly dumb and harmful, it seems that your views should be branded. If you're stupid on one topic, fine, opine on others--and if you trip on those, you will accumulate more tar and more feathers, for all to see. It's been noted that, in the internet age, that a PhD does not automatically confer wisdom, and that formal qualifications have become less important. Right now, civil discourse has an urgent need for disqualifications.
(signed) J. A. Appleman...for a while, thought corn-based ethanol was a reasonable alternative energy source...
I'll put a few possibilities in the comments...please add your own.
The qualifications are minimal. One can earn an advanced degree in seemingly any field, or you can be at a think-tank, or you can be an elected official, or you can have an obsessive blog about a particular subject, or be eloquent, or telegenic, or family of someone relevant, or any of a number of other things. All of these things, whatever their true worth at forming an educated opinion, apparently qualify you to share your opinion with lots of people, and try to sway their opinions.
What distresses me is not how easy it is to gain qualification as an opinion-maker. It is, rather, how it is nearly impossible to be disqualified as an opinioneer. There are too many people whose opinions are given far too much weight, based on how their previous opinions or policies have played out in the real world. They should, one thinks, be disqualified from having publicly broadcast opinions on these matters. We really should never have to listen to a news or opinion piece on human rights from Henry Kissinger, on middle-eastern policy from Dick Cheney, on defence policy from Don Rumsfeld, on presidential powers from John Yoo, on appropriate workplace behavior from Bill Clinton, and so on--except, perhaps to hear them say, "whatever you do, make it the opposite of what I did". But banning people is not the solution, or consistent with our constitution.
So, I argue for the return of the epithet. You may remember epithets from Homer and his ilk: swift-footed Achilles, Eos of the rosy fingers. In documented history, you have kings such as Ethelred the Unready or Ivan the Terrible. These adjectival phrases become part of the character's name. Epithets help us to grasp the essential nature of the person, and they're not always flattering.
There are certain positions or clearly stated opinions--not off-the-cuff remarks, but publicly declared views--that have been tested by time, and found stupid or odious. They become less like opinions and more like falsified hypotheses that are still, despite evidence, clung to. I propose that these should become epithets. However, it doesn't really advance public discourse when you reduce a talking head's world-view to a single adjective like "unready" or "terrible." A more useful and informative epithet, one that would help the audience to weigh an opinion, would be something such as "who thought Sarah Palin would be a good president" or "who reckons that bombing Iran would be constructive," to suggest a few that would apply to the Honorable Senator John McCain.
How does one deal with a bulky and cumbersome epithet such as this? A solution is provided by repurposing yet another scourge of public discourse, the Chyron. Chyrons (the name is apparently a trademark and has nothing to do with the centaur who taught Achilles; they are also called crawls or "the bottom third") are those lines of text that pollute the bottom of a TV screen whenever there is a talking head spouting opinions. They are generally full of garbage, or take the talking head's opinion an reduce it to one phrase of mush. Either way, they do nothing useful. I suggest taking the Chyron and using it to show the talking head's epithet.
Here's an example: nowadays, we see James Inhofe's head talking above lines of text saying "Sen (R) Okla / Jets 14 Ravens 3 (final) / Dow up 13 3/8 / Did Rhianna cheat on Ussher? / Volcanic eruption in Hawaii threatens golf course..." and so on. Instead, we should see James Inhofe talking above lines of text saying "despite a century of accumulated scientific evidence and the assurances of pretty much everybody who has studied them, he refuses to place any credence in biological evolution or anthropogenic climate change. Also gets lots of money from fossil fuel business." That way the viewer would know the talking head is venal and committed to ignorance on not just one, but two, and probably lots of issues.
It might be argued that this would stifle free discussion of important issues. But, if you consistently have opinions that the passage of time have shown to be clearly dumb and harmful, it seems that your views should be branded. If you're stupid on one topic, fine, opine on others--and if you trip on those, you will accumulate more tar and more feathers, for all to see. It's been noted that, in the internet age, that a PhD does not automatically confer wisdom, and that formal qualifications have become less important. Right now, civil discourse has an urgent need for disqualifications.
(signed) J. A. Appleman...for a while, thought corn-based ethanol was a reasonable alternative energy source...
I'll put a few possibilities in the comments...please add your own.
Friday, August 22, 2014
Friday flora--annoying Armenian rubes
There are folks who are just annoying. They seem to always be present, and loud, and
in your way, clingy and hard to escape.
They do exactly the wrong thing at the wrong time, and can’t help but be
unhelpful. They make it hard to get work
done, and hinder your friends. They are
not necessarily evil, indeed, their actions are not personal at all. It’s just that they are a pain through and
through.
Imagine such a person, a total jerk 364 days of the
year. Then one day, that person drops a
really lovely, absolutely exquisite gift on you: a gift that is much
appreciated, that makes your life better for a long time, and actually improves
your social standing.
This week’s flora is the vegetal embodiment of that person—the
Himalayan Blackberry, aka the Armenian Blackberry, aka Rubus armeniacus aka Rubus
discolor. We are at war with this
plant; when we purchased this place, it had a blackberry problem that was
visible from space, or at least on Google maps.
We have been mowing it and siccing our goats on it and spraying it ever
since, and we will be continuing to do so for as long as we are here.
However, once a year, the plants are less odious. For a few days, even in a droughty year such
as this, they are covered with shiny black, plump berries. They are luscious, inviting, compelling,
tart, and other adjectives one might apply to something suggesting moral laxity. So, one goes out with a bucket and a sun hat
and shears and starts gathering berries, one for me, one for the bucket, one
for me, one for the bucket…until one has enough to make some jam or sorbet or
pie. Brother M happened to be here with
his sweetie for a day, and they came, picked, jammed, and left. I spent an afternoon last week doing the
same.
For the record, an hour and a half of picking converts to
five liters of berries, which converts to two and a half liters of juice and
six hundred grams of seeds and pulp. Add
pectin and eleven cups of sugar (interestingly, blackberry seeds sink in
blackberry juice, but the addition of sugar increases the specific gravity
enough that the seeds will float), cook and can, and you’ll end up with just
shy of four liters of jam.
So, now we have a lot
of jam, and it is delicious. It is a universally
fungible as a bribe or lagniappe. It
will be bringing a dose of summer’s sunshine and warmth to a chilly, rainy
March.
Friday, August 1, 2014
Living in the country...pros and cons
Pro: While walking across the big pasture to do the evening rounds, I stopped and took this picture
Con: I soon discovered I was standing at the door of a nest of burrowing yellowjackts.
Only got one sting, and enjoyed a nice run.
Friday, September 28, 2012
Like Clockwork
Anybody who has the slightest connection to the world of lutherie knows that every year, some engineer* in some corner of the world will discover the Secret of Stradivari--some odd treatment or technique that will allow any modern builder to replicate "the" sound** of the classic Cremonese instruments. It's like those of us who follow biology know that every year--at least, if the popular press is to be believed--some researcher will discover "the" cure for cancer. Really, if all the stories in the newspapers claiming that a cure for cancer is just around the corner were true, the dread disease would have been history long ago.
That last sentence should be in quotes--I lifted it verbatim from an article in this week's Economist that discusses a paper about why science journalism sucks with such regularity. The paper*** focuses on the ten journal articles about ADHD that garnered the most attention from the popular media, and what happens after the big splash. It concludes that the findings in each of the "top ten" are novel, generate testable hypotheses, and in eight out of ten cases, are unsupported by subsequent research. The paper refrains from slamming the media, but points out that the popular press is easily impressed by high-impact journals, top-tier universities, and seems unwilling to follow up and look for confirmation of splashy results.
The Economist cops to some blame for this state of affairs, but also apportions some blame to the scientists themselves, because the follow-up articles don't make it into the same high-impact journals. (Nobody mentions one of my least favorite things, the University Press Release, which is often horrible and swallowed whole by the media.) So, it admonishes itself, and then lets itself off the hook.
And, on the very same page, there is this article: "Magic Mushrooms--Violins constructed from infected wood sound like those of Stradivari," about how some engineer in Switzerland has discovered the Secret of Stradivari...
*I don't know why, but it's practically always an engineer
**a bogus goal in itself; for one thing, there is no unified sound of Cremona, or even of any single maker, and for another, one of the things that makes these fiddles so prized is their protean sound.
That last sentence should be in quotes--I lifted it verbatim from an article in this week's Economist that discusses a paper about why science journalism sucks with such regularity. The paper*** focuses on the ten journal articles about ADHD that garnered the most attention from the popular media, and what happens after the big splash. It concludes that the findings in each of the "top ten" are novel, generate testable hypotheses, and in eight out of ten cases, are unsupported by subsequent research. The paper refrains from slamming the media, but points out that the popular press is easily impressed by high-impact journals, top-tier universities, and seems unwilling to follow up and look for confirmation of splashy results.
The Economist cops to some blame for this state of affairs, but also apportions some blame to the scientists themselves, because the follow-up articles don't make it into the same high-impact journals. (Nobody mentions one of my least favorite things, the University Press Release, which is often horrible and swallowed whole by the media.) So, it admonishes itself, and then lets itself off the hook.
And, on the very same page, there is this article: "Magic Mushrooms--Violins constructed from infected wood sound like those of Stradivari," about how some engineer in Switzerland has discovered the Secret of Stradivari...
*I don't know why, but it's practically always an engineer
**a bogus goal in itself; for one thing, there is no unified sound of Cremona, or even of any single maker, and for another, one of the things that makes these fiddles so prized is their protean sound.
***Gonon
F,
Konsman
J-P,
Cohen
D,
Boraud
T
(2012)
Why Most Biomedical Findings Echoed by Newspapers Turn Out to be False: The Case of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.
PLoS ONE 7(9):
e44275.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0044275. It's PLOS, so it's open access, and it's an amusing paper, so go read it.
Saturday, September 8, 2012
what in hell / have i done to deserve / all these kittens
It doesn't make for a very satisfying story: it started in the middle, and as soon as we were introduced to the characters, we knew the ending would not be a totally happy one. This was not the fault of the characters--it was a simple fact of their existence.
We were introduced to the story by accident. As I was walking from workshop to house one hot evening a couple of weeks ago, I noticed that some of the wood that I had so carefully stacked to dry in the woodshed had fallen over. I stuck my head in the shed and shone my flashlight in to see how much of my work had been undone, and saw my orderly stacks made into a jumbled pile. Worse, on top of that pile, at the farthest end of the shed, there were twelve little green eyes shining back at me.
Now, in the right place, I like cats. House cats are fun, and I still miss Unnamed Cat. Barn cats can be both fun and useful. However, I hate feral cats. I knew there was a feral cat on our property, a kind of slinky grey thing that I'd occasionally catch prowling around. I also knew that there were at least two mated pairs of quail living near our house, and that no quail chicks survived this year. So, an upset lumber pile suddenly seemed pretty minor compared to a feral cat population boom. The kittens had to go.
Catching the kittens was a challenge--a jumbled log pile is not especially stable for an adult human, and is extremely porous for a young kitten. After an hour's sweaty work (an adventure in itself--it was dark, so we had to use flashlights, and there was as much effort spent in keeping two eager nine-year-old nephews from injury as corralling kittens), the Real Doctor was able grab three kittens, all hissing and clawing. We called it a night, unsure as to whether the other kittens were alive or dead under the shifting logs.
By the next day, the still-free kittens had escaped the woodpile. They had been moved by their mother into a boarded-up section of one of the sheds, visible and accessible only through a drain. A Havahart trap was obtained, and put up in front of the drain; this was too small for the mother cat, but over the next night two more of the kittens were captured, apparently trying to get to their mother. After that, there was still one more kitten, but it had gotten moved by the wily mother, and we didn't know to where.
This last fugitive was captured when the Real Doctor went to feed the other kittens; I was bringing her some newspaper, and noticed a pair of eyes looking at me from under the stack of hay bales. After walling off the room and throwing the bales aside, we cornered and captured the last of the future bird-murderers.
Our niece, L., immediately gave all the kittens saccharine names, and the Real Doctor immediately called the local animal shelter to see about getting rid of them. Unfortunately they were too young for disposal, and we'd have to fatten them up for a couple of weeks until they were about a kilo each before the shelter wanted them. The niece and nephews were all over this delay, and overnight the kittens expanded in size until they occupied some sixty percent of the universe--at least, in the attention of the kids. To the Real Doctor and me, they were another chore, another set of beasts to feed, and cursed with awful-smelling food to boot.
The relationship between a six-year-old girl and kittens is interesting. They were her obsession, but unfortunately for her, the presence of an adult was definitely necessary for her to play with them. She would "walk" them on a leash and rat-harness, and delightedly proclaim how much Mittens or April loved it--while the kitten was splayed, trying to flatten itself into the floor or any corner, ears back and looking terrified. Eventually, both of the young mammals got slightly better at their respective jobs; the niece would proudly point out that Moppet especially loved being carried around by her, oblivious to the fresh scratches all over her upper body. I guess it is better to live in a pleasant fantasy world than in one in which everything is out to get you.
My relationship with the kittens was still somewhat resentful, and predicated on their ultimate delivery to the animal shelter. (The Real Doctor notes that despite this fact, she started enjoying feeding and playing with the kittens, and started not to mind the smell of the cat food.) I suppose they were cute, and if I wanted to I could have bonded with one. Lab rats are also cute, and I have loved them as pets--but I have also murdered a fair number in my career. At some point in the life of this farm, we're probably going to have to butcher some lambs and chickens. So, I did my best to think of the kittens as things to fatten up and get rid of.
Last week, one of the kittens, Attila/Fluffy (The Real Doctor's name*/the niece's name), got adopted by one of the Real Doctor's co-workers as a house cat. The rest I took to the shelter; they were weighing about a kilo each, the perfect weight for adoption, and thanks to the ministrations of our niece and nephews, they had seen the worst of being broken in. The kitten-dumping process is pretty straightforward: you walk in with the cats, certify that they truly don't belong to anybody else, indicate what you can about their provenance and health, sign a statement that the animals shall be as nothing to me, like the dust of the earth, and walk out without them.
Of course, we were left with the mother to deal with; a brief conversation with our neighbor indicated that she was both hard to catch and, with the assistance of a feral tom up the road, annoyingly fecund. Last year she had a litter in the middle of a wall, requiring destruction of the wall to retrieve them. She is also a good mother; the whole time we were fattening her kittens, she would visit them while we slept, loudly bewail the sorrows of her separation, and leave parting gifts of a rat, a vole, half a bunny, and so on. She easily avoided the medium-size Havahart trap we set next to the kittens, and pretty much all we saw of her was her heels as she ran away. Returning from the animal shelter, I stopped at the Co-op and purchased the larger Havahart, and the Real Doctor baited it with some of the stinky cat food and put it next to the now-empty kitten cages.
The next morning, I found Momma Cat in the cage--I almost didn't see her at first, and thought the trap had sprung shut on nothing, since she was dark grey and hidden in the shadows. She looked at me with a fair amount of what I project to be hate, fear, and confusion:
So, it was another trip to the animal shelter, and here we come to the unsatisfying end of the tale. Per the terms of the drop-off, I am not allowed to seek any information about any of the animals; they may get new homes, or they may be euthanised. For kittens, The Real Doctor informs me that the odds are favorable, but they are still odds. For Momma Cat, the odds are worse: she is smart and good looking, an excellent mouser and mother, but feral and lousy pet material. When you read this, she may be dead, executed for the crime of following biological imperatives. The Real Doctor and I both feel some guilt about this--perhaps owing to our own inability to follow the same imperatives--and I made some atonement by a cash donation to the animal shelter. But it's still not a satisfying story. Next year, when we have clearer heads and more time and a more stable environment, we may get a kitten.
****************
The first thing I thought when I saw the kittens in the woodshed, and perhaps an epitaph for Momma Cat, was an archy-and-mehitabel poem by Don Marquis**:
mehitabel and her kittens
well boss
mehitabel the cat
has reappeared in her old
haunts with a
flock of kittens
three of them this time
archy she says to me
yesterday
the life of a female
artist is continually
hampered what in hell
have i done to deserve
all these kittens
i look back on my life
and it seems to me to be
just one damned kitten
after another
i am a dancer archy
and my only prayer
is to be allowed
to give my best to my art
but just as i feel
that i am succeeding
in my life work
along comes another batch
of these damned kittens
it is not archy
that i am shy on mother love
god knows i care for
the sweet little things
curse them
but am i never to be allowed
to live my own life
i have purposely avoided
matrimony in the interests
of the higher life
but i might just
as well have been a domestic
slave for all the freedom
i have gained
i hope none of them
gets run over by
an automobile
my heart would bleed
if anything happened
to them and i found it out
but it isn t fair archy
it isn t fair
these damned tom cats have all
the fun and freedom
if i was like some of these
green eyed feline vamps i know
i would simply walk out on the
bunch of them and
let them shift for themselves
but i am not that kind
archy i am full of mother love
my kindness has always
been my curse
a tender heart is the cross i bear
self sacrifice always and forever
is my motto damn them
i will make a home
for the sweet innocent
little things
unless of course providence
in his wisdom should remove
them they are living
just now in an abandoned
garbage can just behind
a made over stable in greenwich
village and if it rained
into the can before i could
get back and rescue them
i am afraid the little
dears might drown
it makes me shudder just
to think of it
of course if i were a family cat
they would probably
be drowned anyhow
sometimes i think
the kinder thing would be
for me to carry the
sweet little things
over to the river
and drop them in myself
but a mother s love archy
is so unreasonable
something always prevents me
these terrible
conflicts are always
presenting themselves
to the artist
the eternal struggle
between art and life archy
is something fierce
my what a dramatic life i have lived
one moment up the next
moment down again
but always gay archy always gay
and always the lady too
in spite of hell
well boss it will
be interesting to note
just how mehitabel
works out her present problem
a dark mystery still broods
over the manner
in which the former
family of three kittens
disappeared
one day she was taking to me
of the kittens
and the next day when i asked
her about them
she said innocently
what kittens
interrogation point
and that was all
i could ever get out
of her on the subject
we had a heavy rain
right after she spoke to me
but probably that garbage can
leaks so the kittens
have not yet
been drowned
**The poem is written from the point of view of archy, a vers libre poet who was reincarnated as a cockroach who pals around with mehitabel, a cat on her ninth life. You should read the entire collection.
We were introduced to the story by accident. As I was walking from workshop to house one hot evening a couple of weeks ago, I noticed that some of the wood that I had so carefully stacked to dry in the woodshed had fallen over. I stuck my head in the shed and shone my flashlight in to see how much of my work had been undone, and saw my orderly stacks made into a jumbled pile. Worse, on top of that pile, at the farthest end of the shed, there were twelve little green eyes shining back at me.
Now, in the right place, I like cats. House cats are fun, and I still miss Unnamed Cat. Barn cats can be both fun and useful. However, I hate feral cats. I knew there was a feral cat on our property, a kind of slinky grey thing that I'd occasionally catch prowling around. I also knew that there were at least two mated pairs of quail living near our house, and that no quail chicks survived this year. So, an upset lumber pile suddenly seemed pretty minor compared to a feral cat population boom. The kittens had to go.
Catching the kittens was a challenge--a jumbled log pile is not especially stable for an adult human, and is extremely porous for a young kitten. After an hour's sweaty work (an adventure in itself--it was dark, so we had to use flashlights, and there was as much effort spent in keeping two eager nine-year-old nephews from injury as corralling kittens), the Real Doctor was able grab three kittens, all hissing and clawing. We called it a night, unsure as to whether the other kittens were alive or dead under the shifting logs.
By the next day, the still-free kittens had escaped the woodpile. They had been moved by their mother into a boarded-up section of one of the sheds, visible and accessible only through a drain. A Havahart trap was obtained, and put up in front of the drain; this was too small for the mother cat, but over the next night two more of the kittens were captured, apparently trying to get to their mother. After that, there was still one more kitten, but it had gotten moved by the wily mother, and we didn't know to where.
This last fugitive was captured when the Real Doctor went to feed the other kittens; I was bringing her some newspaper, and noticed a pair of eyes looking at me from under the stack of hay bales. After walling off the room and throwing the bales aside, we cornered and captured the last of the future bird-murderers.
Our niece, L., immediately gave all the kittens saccharine names, and the Real Doctor immediately called the local animal shelter to see about getting rid of them. Unfortunately they were too young for disposal, and we'd have to fatten them up for a couple of weeks until they were about a kilo each before the shelter wanted them. The niece and nephews were all over this delay, and overnight the kittens expanded in size until they occupied some sixty percent of the universe--at least, in the attention of the kids. To the Real Doctor and me, they were another chore, another set of beasts to feed, and cursed with awful-smelling food to boot.
The relationship between a six-year-old girl and kittens is interesting. They were her obsession, but unfortunately for her, the presence of an adult was definitely necessary for her to play with them. She would "walk" them on a leash and rat-harness, and delightedly proclaim how much Mittens or April loved it--while the kitten was splayed, trying to flatten itself into the floor or any corner, ears back and looking terrified. Eventually, both of the young mammals got slightly better at their respective jobs; the niece would proudly point out that Moppet especially loved being carried around by her, oblivious to the fresh scratches all over her upper body. I guess it is better to live in a pleasant fantasy world than in one in which everything is out to get you.
My relationship with the kittens was still somewhat resentful, and predicated on their ultimate delivery to the animal shelter. (The Real Doctor notes that despite this fact, she started enjoying feeding and playing with the kittens, and started not to mind the smell of the cat food.) I suppose they were cute, and if I wanted to I could have bonded with one. Lab rats are also cute, and I have loved them as pets--but I have also murdered a fair number in my career. At some point in the life of this farm, we're probably going to have to butcher some lambs and chickens. So, I did my best to think of the kittens as things to fatten up and get rid of.
Last week, one of the kittens, Attila/Fluffy (The Real Doctor's name*/the niece's name), got adopted by one of the Real Doctor's co-workers as a house cat. The rest I took to the shelter; they were weighing about a kilo each, the perfect weight for adoption, and thanks to the ministrations of our niece and nephews, they had seen the worst of being broken in. The kitten-dumping process is pretty straightforward: you walk in with the cats, certify that they truly don't belong to anybody else, indicate what you can about their provenance and health, sign a statement that the animals shall be as nothing to me, like the dust of the earth, and walk out without them.
Of course, we were left with the mother to deal with; a brief conversation with our neighbor indicated that she was both hard to catch and, with the assistance of a feral tom up the road, annoyingly fecund. Last year she had a litter in the middle of a wall, requiring destruction of the wall to retrieve them. She is also a good mother; the whole time we were fattening her kittens, she would visit them while we slept, loudly bewail the sorrows of her separation, and leave parting gifts of a rat, a vole, half a bunny, and so on. She easily avoided the medium-size Havahart trap we set next to the kittens, and pretty much all we saw of her was her heels as she ran away. Returning from the animal shelter, I stopped at the Co-op and purchased the larger Havahart, and the Real Doctor baited it with some of the stinky cat food and put it next to the now-empty kitten cages.
The next morning, I found Momma Cat in the cage--I almost didn't see her at first, and thought the trap had sprung shut on nothing, since she was dark grey and hidden in the shadows. She looked at me with a fair amount of what I project to be hate, fear, and confusion:
So, it was another trip to the animal shelter, and here we come to the unsatisfying end of the tale. Per the terms of the drop-off, I am not allowed to seek any information about any of the animals; they may get new homes, or they may be euthanised. For kittens, The Real Doctor informs me that the odds are favorable, but they are still odds. For Momma Cat, the odds are worse: she is smart and good looking, an excellent mouser and mother, but feral and lousy pet material. When you read this, she may be dead, executed for the crime of following biological imperatives. The Real Doctor and I both feel some guilt about this--perhaps owing to our own inability to follow the same imperatives--and I made some atonement by a cash donation to the animal shelter. But it's still not a satisfying story. Next year, when we have clearer heads and more time and a more stable environment, we may get a kitten.
****************
The first thing I thought when I saw the kittens in the woodshed, and perhaps an epitaph for Momma Cat, was an archy-and-mehitabel poem by Don Marquis**:
mehitabel and her kittens
well boss
mehitabel the cat
has reappeared in her old
haunts with a
flock of kittens
three of them this time
archy she says to me
yesterday
the life of a female
artist is continually
hampered what in hell
have i done to deserve
all these kittens
i look back on my life
and it seems to me to be
just one damned kitten
after another
i am a dancer archy
and my only prayer
is to be allowed
to give my best to my art
but just as i feel
that i am succeeding
in my life work
along comes another batch
of these damned kittens
it is not archy
that i am shy on mother love
god knows i care for
the sweet little things
curse them
but am i never to be allowed
to live my own life
i have purposely avoided
matrimony in the interests
of the higher life
but i might just
as well have been a domestic
slave for all the freedom
i have gained
i hope none of them
gets run over by
an automobile
my heart would bleed
if anything happened
to them and i found it out
but it isn t fair archy
it isn t fair
these damned tom cats have all
the fun and freedom
if i was like some of these
green eyed feline vamps i know
i would simply walk out on the
bunch of them and
let them shift for themselves
but i am not that kind
archy i am full of mother love
my kindness has always
been my curse
a tender heart is the cross i bear
self sacrifice always and forever
is my motto damn them
i will make a home
for the sweet innocent
little things
unless of course providence
in his wisdom should remove
them they are living
just now in an abandoned
garbage can just behind
a made over stable in greenwich
village and if it rained
into the can before i could
get back and rescue them
i am afraid the little
dears might drown
it makes me shudder just
to think of it
of course if i were a family cat
they would probably
be drowned anyhow
sometimes i think
the kinder thing would be
for me to carry the
sweet little things
over to the river
and drop them in myself
but a mother s love archy
is so unreasonable
something always prevents me
these terrible
conflicts are always
presenting themselves
to the artist
the eternal struggle
between art and life archy
is something fierce
my what a dramatic life i have lived
one moment up the next
moment down again
but always gay archy always gay
and always the lady too
in spite of hell
well boss it will
be interesting to note
just how mehitabel
works out her present problem
a dark mystery still broods
over the manner
in which the former
family of three kittens
disappeared
one day she was taking to me
of the kittens
and the next day when i asked
her about them
she said innocently
what kittens
interrogation point
and that was all
i could ever get out
of her on the subject
we had a heavy rain
right after she spoke to me
but probably that garbage can
leaks so the kittens
have not yet
been drowned
- archy
**The poem is written from the point of view of archy, a vers libre poet who was reincarnated as a cockroach who pals around with mehitabel, a cat on her ninth life. You should read the entire collection.
Monday, July 9, 2012
Friday Flora egregious error edition
It would have to be a big mistake to have a Friday Flora on Monday.
It would be a worse mistake to think that that's what poison oak looks like. That's poison ivy. If you were hiking around here, you would itch so bad. Full page ad on the back of the Economist; I suppose that you wouldn't encounter either in the UK.
It would be a worse mistake to think that that's what poison oak looks like. That's poison ivy. If you were hiking around here, you would itch so bad. Full page ad on the back of the Economist; I suppose that you wouldn't encounter either in the UK.
Monday, March 26, 2012
Amphibious
I sometimes feel like I live in two parallel universes, the inhabitants of which don't really know about each other.
Last week saw me participating in the adventure of air travel, which gave me the chance to dig into some back issues of Science, and this evening I had a chat with brother M., who told me about his lesson plan for his environmental science class tomorrow. In this world, everyone knows that evolution happens and is well documented, and there are really neat studies being done right now that give insights into the detailed mechanisms and pace of evolutionary change. In this world, a driver of evolutionary change is a climate that is changing due to human activity. Everybody in this world knows about it, and sees the evidence in every nook and cranny of the environment. Heck, everybody in this world even calls the current geologic era the "Anthropocene." Everybody in this world knows why it's happening, and what ought to be done about it.
Traveling by air, one also gets treated to the journalistic stylings of Fox News and the Wall Street Journal and all manner of political opinion--when I looked up from my magazines, I felt like I had portaled into a parallel world where teaching evolution is highly questionable, and where the politicians preferred by about half of the populace denied the existence of climate change and vehemently denied that humans had any role in the problem. It causes a sort of psychic whiplash, this tunneling back and forth between universes. As I was saying to brother M., it must be really nice to live in that universe where the laws of physics don't obtain.
Last week saw me participating in the adventure of air travel, which gave me the chance to dig into some back issues of Science, and this evening I had a chat with brother M., who told me about his lesson plan for his environmental science class tomorrow. In this world, everyone knows that evolution happens and is well documented, and there are really neat studies being done right now that give insights into the detailed mechanisms and pace of evolutionary change. In this world, a driver of evolutionary change is a climate that is changing due to human activity. Everybody in this world knows about it, and sees the evidence in every nook and cranny of the environment. Heck, everybody in this world even calls the current geologic era the "Anthropocene." Everybody in this world knows why it's happening, and what ought to be done about it.
Traveling by air, one also gets treated to the journalistic stylings of Fox News and the Wall Street Journal and all manner of political opinion--when I looked up from my magazines, I felt like I had portaled into a parallel world where teaching evolution is highly questionable, and where the politicians preferred by about half of the populace denied the existence of climate change and vehemently denied that humans had any role in the problem. It causes a sort of psychic whiplash, this tunneling back and forth between universes. As I was saying to brother M., it must be really nice to live in that universe where the laws of physics don't obtain.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


